10 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
hawaiian
hawaiian
14 years ago

Digging the sideways mention of Dale Carnegie’s How to Win Friends and Influence Others at 59:00 🙂

Ken Keller
Ken Keller
14 years ago

Just listened to Episode 547,’Great Podcast”, Jack, keep up the good work of keeping us informed, your a real American Patriot, Thakyou.

Rick
Rick
14 years ago

Outstanding episode. You did a great job of summing some of our ideas up. Also great to share with people who may not understand the ideas modern survivalism.

Solitary Grey Wolf
Solitary Grey Wolf
14 years ago

Doesn’t matter the term. Pick your life. Forget what the man says and the concepts of how you must live. Picket fences are bullshit. Keep your office. I’ll take the campfire, the sunset, the cabin and the comfort of steel on my hip and fresh meat in my gut.

Thank you Jack. What I see in my mind can be and is.

Granny Miller
14 years ago

Jack –
You are doing some very good work.

That said, IMHO this a complected topic and you missed the mark on this podcast 🙁

You seemingly lack the historical and literary foundation to intelligently discuss this topic. I fear you may be doing you listeners a disservice.

I would very strongly encourage you to read more general American History, classic agrarian literature and traditional Christian authors.

Ragnar Benson, St.Benedict of Nursia, Louis Bromfield, Thomas Jefferson, Gene Logsdon, David Henry Thoreau, John Seymour, Catherine Beecher Stowe, Wendell Berry, Wes Jackson and Katie Luther are good sources that come to mind this morning.
Please feel free to not publish this comment.
It is not my intent to criticize your work in a public venue, but I did want to leave you feedback.
All the best,
GM

richard
14 years ago

Hi Jack,
I am Granny’s husband, and agree that you are both doing some great work and missed the point with this one.

1. Your great work is the idea that the survivalist movement needs to move from storing food (consumerism) to home production (agrarianism). Your message about things like debt cancer is spot on! Keep it up!

2. our disagreement is your characterization of homesteaders as the original survivalists, and the necessity of an “individualist mindset”. While we would agree that labels are just conveniences, the homesteader is more defined by his relationship to land and neighbors. If I have a criticism against many survivalists, it is that if each retreats to his own hidey hole, the worthy idea of civilization vanishes. After decades of homesteading, we look more self sufficient on the outside, but what has really grown is the ties to like minded neighbors and family. We make certain decisions about how our lives effect our neighbors, and we are anything but individualistic.

The references to the Christian authors is not about pushing theology, but about the idea of the homestead as a building block of local economies. One not need be a Roman Catholic to appreciate the role of St Benedict in rebuilding European agriculture after the fall of Rome. One need not be a Lutheran to see the contribution of Katie Luther to revitalizing the idea of the family centered economy.

richard
14 years ago

Hi Jack,
Thank you for the clarification, I think I understand your point better.